25 Most Valuable Nickels for Coin Collectors 

25.1964-D Repunched Mintmark $19,800

24.2000-P Two-Headed Nickel $20,000

23.1939 Doubled Monticello $20,000

22.1962 Full Steps Jefferson Nickel $21,000

21.1964 Full Steps Satin Finish $23,000

20.1939 Reverse of 1940 $24,000

19.1953-5 Full Steps Jefferson Nickel $24,000

18.1940 Reverse of 1938 Nickel $29,000

17.1942-D D Over Horizontal D $32,000

16.1964 Full Steps Special Mint Set $33,000

15.1949-D D Over S Full Steps Jefferson $33,000

14.1938-D Full Steps Jefferson Nickel $34,000

13.1935 Buffalo Nickel Doubled Die $147,000

12.1919-5 Buffalo Nickel $157,000

11.1918-S Buffalo Nickel $170,000

10.1920-D Buffalo Nickel $186,000

9.1917-5 Buffalo Nickel $186,000

8.1913-D Buffalo Nickel Type 2 $194,000

7.1867 Shield Nickel with Rays $203,000

6.1880 Shield Nickel $209,000

5.1916 Buffalo Nickel Doubled Die $433,000

4.1926-5 Buffalo Nickel $435,000

3.1918-D Buffalo Nickel Double Die $505,000

2.1964 Jefferson Nickel Mirror $1.15 million

1.1913 Liberty Head V Nickel $4.6 million